Skip to main content

Selection of chords inside the harmonizer..

Posted

Is there a way to access, specify, or paste additional/alternate chords inside the harmonizer other than the ones that are recommended by the current selection heuristics?


Tue, 2009-03-03 - 00:14 Permalink

Select the desired position and insert a new transition point using the button. That will create a new selection of chords to choose from.

Thanks for the report. Actually chords should not be added this way, but it sounds like an interesting thought.

Tue, 2009-03-03 - 01:03 Permalink

I should add it as a feature request then.

I was thinking outside the box a little bit, seeing if there was a way to get some alternate chords into the harmonizer that weren't necessarily being displayed at the moment.

Tue, 2009-03-03 - 20:31 Permalink

[quote="keith_phillips"]I was thinking outside the box a little bit, seeing if there was a way to get some alternate chords into the harmonizer that weren't necessarily being displayed at the moment.

Interesting thread. The harmonizer is the only feature I've really given up working with because it never seems to offer the chords I want. So I would definitely welcome the ability to add chords apart from the ones which synfire suggests.

When recognising imported figures I used to create the full progression in a progression editor and then just paste it in which seemed to work without a problem. I did this before recognising figures. However, I seem to remember someone saying in another thread that figure recognition is independent of harmony so I now think I was wasting my time! Is that right?

Tim

Tue, 2009-03-03 - 20:43 Permalink

Figure recognition doesn't seem to be completely removed from harmony in my experience, as I seemed to have some incorrectly created figures when the harmony was somewhat far off...which was the reason why I have been working on getting my head around using the harmonizer better.

Tue, 2009-03-03 - 21:54 Permalink

@Tim: The opposite is true: Figure recognition is /impossible/ without a progression that can serve as a reference (it's the harmonizer which is only marginally influenced by an already existing progression).

In fact, a good harmonization is the best preparation for subsequent figure recognition. Your approach to do a manual harmonization first and then run the recognition on the bare Take again is correct. In most cases this leads to better results than the fully automated import batch.

This is also the standard workflow in the phrase pool editor, where one builds phrase libraries from scratch.

The harmonizer's suggestions largely depend on the correct key assumption. If you accidentally pick the major/minor parallel, you will already see less optimal results. Also make sure there is enough input to harmonize.

My standard procedure is to have the harmonizer create a rough guess and then tweak the progression using palettes or by just adding extensions to the chords.

Andre

Tue, 2009-03-03 - 22:13 Permalink

So Andre, I guess a further refinement of my original question is: should the "physical" harmony parameter be the one that is ultimately tweaked and set for figure recognition? ...or is it the "guessed-but-also-somewhat-tweakable" harmony setting (bottom gray area) in the harmonizer?

I noticed that you can have a progression already set, and the harmonizer doesn't necessarily match up to what is set in the progression.

edit: I mention this because it is often easier for me to use the harmonizer to derive the progression, especially when no figure exists. Just that when I apply the changes and further go *back* into the harmonizer, I have no easy way to bring the current "working" progression back in to the harmonizer for audible tweaking (if that makes any sense.)

Tue, 2009-03-03 - 22:43 Permalink

Yes, its the "physical" parameter assigned/set for the container that matters for figure recognition.

The other one shown at the bottom of the harmonizer's vector view is only temporary -- it shows your current selection. Unless you accept it for the container (by pressing the Apply button), it will be lost when closing the window.

The harmonizer remembers your last selections between sessions, btw. Although this information is lost when the file is saved to disk (not persistent).

Tue, 2009-03-03 - 22:54 Permalink

Would it be possible then to add a function to extract the current "working" harmony parameter into the harmonizer for tweaking? I think it does this currently in a round-about sort of way if you clear the harmonizer and hit apply. It could be a useful feature I think.

I tried copy and paste but I don't think it worked when I did...

Wed, 2009-03-04 - 21:20 Permalink

Andre,

Thank you for explaining all that. I hadn't understood the way the container progression interacted with the progression in the harmonizer.

Tim