Direkt zum Inhalt

Nesting level Synfire Express too little

Posted

When i build up my arrangements of different sections what contained subcontainers

  • Intro group
  • main group.
  • extra instrument group
  • chord group
  • fill in group
  • ending group
  • ...

I like to store all these groups in a another head group container.  
Example : suppose i do have  position a fill group between two maingroups ( for this i must make a extra (head) group for each main group )(= nesting level 2) ..now i can easily the two head containers wherein each of the  two maingroups  are contained reposition in the arrangement window and add the fill in container between them.

So a 2e nestinglevel is needed for getting more freedom in the arrangement 
--------------------------------------------------------------------

So i do need one more nesting level ( default is 1 for Synfire Express )

-------------------------------------------------------------------  

 

Further the container manipulation ...with keyboard keys

In a matrix of containers contained in a group container i like to reposition the container also in horizontal direction with the left or richt cursor ( Like in vertical direction is possible: i select a container and i can exchance the container position vertical in a column--> also when synfire is playing live in a loop ..that is good )

 

Is it possible to get the same easy repositioning of the containersin a matrix for the horizontal direction ( like for the vertical position ) ? 

  •  

Do., 21.02.2013 - 22:31 Permalink

Ok with one nesting level you can do it to setup your arrangement ,, but the big shortcoming of Synfire Express is that it has no articulation for modern popmusic  sounds found in HALion 4 ( guitar , sax, and some more )
It is not the music studio program where you can express your self with articulated sounds..it is boring. 

 

Do., 21.02.2013 - 23:58 Permalink

In my opinion most modern synths use midi cc to modulate their sounds and synfire express supports this. Generally only sample based instruments use keyswitches to change to different sample sets for a sound. However have you tried adding a separate 'track' on the same channel and using static notes to effect the keyswitch changes? You might even be able to merge the two tracks together although I haven't mixed static and other types in the same 'track' so I don't know if this works.
Alternatively maybe your daw can be setup to convert midi cc to keyswitch notes? Lastly if you have some instruments free in synfire express maybe you could setup the same instrument but with a different keyswitch enabled?

Fr., 22.02.2013 - 00:14 Permalink

However have you tried adding a separate 'track' on the same channel and using static notes to effect the keyswitch changes?

 

I love createive, 'outside the box' work arounds. Good thinking, blacksun!

Fr., 22.02.2013 - 01:35 Permalink

 No idea how this works ?
There is a trick to do this and it is mentioned here on the forum here earlier, but i did nothing with it , at that time Bild entfernt.

Alternatively maybe your daw can be setup to convert midi cc to keyswitch notes?

 

For keyswitching, try this. On your 'instrument' (which I would prefer to call a 'track' that is linked to a prototying algorithm defined by a specific GM instrument) with the sax try adding a static note at the point of the key switch and keep adjusting it until you find where it triggers the VSTi keyswitch. Once you find one keyswitch, you know you are near the other ones. So you see if the articulation you want is triggered.

 

I can't remember if you can use a keyboard to add midi notes to a take? If you could, this would be very easy.

 

It would also be a great feature if you could click on a static note and have a little window open telling you what note it is and then be able to edit the note in that window.

 

Some instruments permit you to change the location of the trigger notes, so to save time you could make sure they are alwasy set up the same way, i.e., the first trigger note at C-1, etc., etc.

 

I think I will try this with Halion Sonic.

Fr., 22.02.2013 - 09:57 Permalink

But i don't see the necessity to go immediately to Synfire Pro !
Synfire Express is targed  as a mainstream studiocomposer for the mass ..like Cubase ( now with the new scorecomposer what is under development..awesome )

I think, by adding some articulationsounds in Synfire Express it becomes a much more attractive  modern composer.

I don't have plans to upgrade to Synfire Pro forthe near future, i am hoping that that Synfire Express gets his articulations ..who knows? 

 

 

Fr., 22.02.2013 - 10:14 Permalink

 

For keyswitching, try this. On your 'instrument' (which I would prefer to call a 'track' that is linked to a prototying algorithm defined by a specific GM instrument) with the sax try adding a static note at the point of the key switch and keep adjusting it until you find where it triggers the VSTi keyswitch. Once you find one keyswitch, you know you are near the other ones. So you see if the articulation you want is triggered.

Thanks!

Ok..i understand it now ( "the coin is fallen" : as we said in Dutch, but is my free proverb ;) )  i add static notes on the sax track what triggers my keyswitch in HALion 4 ; ).. .that's look the same idea what Steinberg is using with the expressionmap.

HALion 4 uses a Midi module : key switch remote ..what has 3 Key Switch Modes ( Keyswitch/Remapped and Controller) and a Midi module: Key switch alternate.
Halion4 shows the keyswitch area on a keyboard for original and remapped area..let me try to add static notes !

Fr., 22.02.2013 - 13:58 Permalink

 In my opinion most modern synths use midi cc to modulate their sounds and synfire express supports this.

That's luckily in Synfre this midi CC, otherwise it becomes a poor arrangement.

However have you tried adding a separate 'track' on the same channel and using static notes to effect the keyswitch changes? You might even be able to merge the two tracks together although I haven't mixed static and other types in the same 'track' so I don't know if this works.

 No idea how this works ?
There is a trick to do this and it is mentioned here on the forum here earlier, but i did nothing with it , at that time :)

Alternatively maybe your daw can be setup to convert midi cc to keyswitch notes?

Problem is here how to convert this ?..as earlier dicussed here

Lastly if you have some instruments free in synfire express maybe you could setup the same instrument but with a different keyswitch enabled?

Interesting, but for instance the sax in HALion has 8 articulations to name something..and 16 channels is the max of Synfire Express. 

So if you go on the jazz tour with a sax and  jazz guitar, probably you have used 16 channels for the articulations 
This is a dead end.

Thanks ..good ideas

 

Fr., 22.02.2013 - 14:07 Permalink

Thanks @Blacksun for your ideas!

I just did some manipulations with the absolute pitch symbols in Synfire E

- My lowest keyswitch area on the HALion 4 keyboard starts default on C-2--> i don't get this pitch C-2 with a absolute symbol  ..it is bound by the middle instrument sound ranges dictated by Synfire. ( choosen by me in the arrrangement window ) 

I think i must adjust the middle soundrange for the SAX and drag the needed pitches there in instrument range  

Fr., 22.02.2013 - 15:00 Permalink

I did make some progress.. finally!

See enclosed pics ..it seems to be rather easy now to assign the keyswitch in HALion to static symbols
Beware that the existing used instrument range must be extended to the lower keyregions, before the static symbols can be trigger the keyswitch.

Note: i made a mistake in the pic F#-1 pitch  must be articulation : "Doits No Attacks"   and not articulation Falls Long no Attack on F-1

But it works the same like now in Cubase...When HALion on the same time is opened with Synfire you can see in HALion 4 easy the note Pitch value in the tab : parameter inspector.

Sounds good !..now only learning more about the sax articulations and others in HALion 4
It seems rather easy to do, to assign the static symbols as triggernotes for the keyswitches in HAlion 4.
A long desired feature has now become reality...but Cubase has still a easier way of working and it work there a lot more easy and better to assign the articulations.
So this is rather simple in Synfire Express compared with Cubase 6.5 ( there you have a easy oversight of what articulation is used ( name written on it, coloring )

So if it is possible to chance the outlook of the static notes...name on it and perhaps with coloring ?
Perhaps it is possible in Synfire E add a new class of Symbols for articulation ?   

 

Fr., 22.02.2013 - 15:34 Permalink

Glad you got it working :) look forward to hearing some of your tunes using it. Would be good to post two versions one with and one without s we can compare.
I'm surprised that static pitch notes are affected by the playing ranges, I learn something new everyday.
Will be interested to see if cognitone add what you are asking for to synfire express as its one of the published benefits of synfire pro, only they can say.

Fr., 22.02.2013 - 19:53 Permalink

It would be nice if  SFP/SFE had a switch which would let extremely high and low notes pass thru unaffected. Many soft and hardware instruments use octave 0 or octave 7 -8 for articulations. Once you get used to using the articulations, it's difficult to do without them.  Ultimately it might be nice to be able to finish a whole piece within it.

 

I strip out the Tyros 4 articulations (hight notes, and high velocity) to work in SFP, and then have to add them back later when I re-import into Logic. 

Sa., 23.02.2013 - 13:19 Permalink

i tried to make a tune with the articulation in Synfire express by using a static track
As aspected it is not suitable for doing this the static track for more complex multiple articulations ..easy and quick.
Note manipulations on the static track is too much work and clumsy, if the instrument track and the static notes are in the same editor track. ( i must scroll down the static notes to the right octave and all is very small to be seen )  

There also not loop recording possible to add the articulations, although  with the keyboard i can add articulations from HAlion 4 and these triggernotes must be recorded than

Live adding multiple articulations is not the workflow for Cubase, but there it works in the editor ..so the same must be for Synfire.

I will will try a demo of Synfire pro and looking how it is there working adding articulations to get a idea if it is there easy to add articulations and keep oversight.  

 

 

Mo., 25.02.2013 - 16:22 Permalink

Synfire will also tranpose these 'too high' notes to a more suitable range, which makes them useless for articulationl. Tyros 4 will also make use of low note key on's to trigger effects/

Mo., 25.02.2013 - 18:20 Permalink

Have you tried creating a device template/dummy sound with a note range at the maximum, then using the import midi using this instrument as static?

Mo., 04.03.2013 - 22:02 Permalink

No, cause even if I tried to manipulate the data on a track, the articulations would be affected,   a time change would be OK, but not any pitch transformation..

 

I did import the articulations as a seperate static track seperate from the musical data.  But in the end, it was easy to strip off the articulations, import into SFP and re-attach later when I got it back into Logic.

 

I often just take the drum track, transpose it to the right area, try a radical velocity random function, and delete all events under a certain velocity and use them as articulations.  I keep a few tracks around which are just articulations.  I load these into Logic, and hand manipulate them to my satisfaction.