Posted
How does the up or down keyboard arrow work? Does one press move the phrase up or down one chord root, as in from the root key up to 1st inversion?
Thanks.
Prado
Sun, 2012-10-14 - 12:47 Permalink
The only thing that can be said with certainty is that the arrow keys move the selected phrase segment one line up or down in the phrase editor grid. What this means musically depends on many factors, among others: The symbol type (color) of the phrase, the settings at the interpretetation parameter, the harmonic context, the setting 'bypass voice leading' on or off, the phrases at the other instruments, the settings for the pitch ranges and typical pitches, and so on. Honestly, I have given up long ago to try to understand exactly what and why Synfire does or does not in a particular situation. Meanwhile, I am perfectly satisfied that I get good musical results. I do not necessarily understand everything.
So, perhaps the best answer to your question is: If you select a phrase segment and press the arrow up key then it will tend to sound a bit higher (probably one scale step) and if you press the arrow down key it will probably sound a bit lower.
Sun, 2012-10-14 - 13:08 Permalink
I often treat synfire as a magic box, only my ears tell me if its good or bad magic that it weaves with each change, and my mood dictates if the change, good or evil, stays or gets cmd-zeded... Lol
But Juergen is right, generally the up arrow makes the pitch higher and the down, lower. That is unless playing ranges or something else dictate an inversion is needed.
Sun, 2012-10-14 - 17:54 Permalink
Thank you, Gentlemen.
I can live with trust my ears. I have a harder time living with what I may suspect is correctable ignorance about something. I'll conclude the answer is 'it all depends.'
Maybe some day I'll make the effort to render a series of short midi files of the same phrase in several contexts with different numbers of clicks, and then examine the results.
I think it will probably be one step in the scale of the main key, full or half step depending, or one jump in the triad.
I barely grasp 'voice leading,' so I am yet to try and suss out that parameter or the other 'break' one.
Prado